Judge to Rule on Appeal of Fines Against Wingham Coffee Shop

Source: WFP
Date: Fri Jul 5 03:39:42 MST 2024

(Wingham, ON) On July 11th at 10:30 am, Judge T.G. MacDonald will deliver a crucial ruling on the appeal of $6,900 in fines issued against Buck & Jo’s, a coffee shop in Wingham, Ontario. These fines were originally imposed by Justice Of The Peace Frank Leddy, who now faces scrutiny for potential errors in his judgment.

The fines stem from a series of contentious interactions between Buck & Jo’s and Huron Perth Public Health (HPPH) inspectors. The coffee shop owners, notably Buck, have publicly and repeatedly stated that they would lock their doors before the compliance deadline rather than infringe upon their customers’ rights. They argue that this decision was a political statement and should not warrant punishment.

Allegations have emerged against HPPH inspectors, including dereliction of duty, refusal to conduct inspections, and refusal to answer pertinent questions. Videos capturing these interactions have gone viral, amassing over 250,000 views, showing Buck firmly standing his ground against inspectors who failed to perform their duties adequately.

One key aspect of the case is the admission by HPPH that their inspectors did not have the authority to check photo identification and health information of customers. They conceded that without this authority, they could not impose such responsibilities on Buck or any other individual.

This case raises an important legal question: Does a business have the right to shut down before a compliance deadline to avoid legal complications? The outcome could set a significant precedent for similar cases in the future.

The controversy includes allegations of perjury against HPPH inspectors and claims of intimidation tactics. During the first visit by HPPH, an Ontario Provincial Police (OPP) officer accompanied the inspector with his hand on his gun, demanding compliance with the inspection. Contrary to HPPH’s claims, video evidence disproves allegations that Buck brandished a weapon during the interaction.

Despite the restaurant being closed a week before the incident and remaining closed for months afterward, it was fined $6,900, a sum notably higher than fines for some drunk driving offenses, which are typically around $1,500. There were also inconsistencies in the inspectors’ testimonies, with one inspector falsely claiming to have read online that the dining room would be open for indoor dining. HPPH issued and then deleted a press release that inaccurately stated they had shut down the dining room, which was already closed at the time.

The case has been drawn out over 972 days, with accusations that the prosecution has been profiting from the extended proceedings. Inspectors allegedly provided around 30 inconsistent statements during the trial. Justice Of The Peace Leddy has been criticized for his handling of the case, including admitting multiple times that he could not keep up with the proceedings and failing to obtain a trial transcript, leading to potential errors in his ruling.

Judge MacDonald’s upcoming decision will address these controversies and the broader implications for businesses facing similar situations. The hearing will be available for public viewing via a Zoom link. https://ca01web.zoom.us/j/64074406397?pwd dUNjcnE5K1k4R2N4TkxvT1JtUGtpZz09

This case highlights the challenges and complexities of enforcing health regulations and the rights of businesses in navigating compliance issues. The outcome will be closely watched by legal experts, business owners, and the public alike.


Hamilton Police Service




























Latest Headlines

Murder Update: Justus CHESTER Arrested & Victim Identified
Kyle DRAKE – Drunk Driving
Kimberley SKILL Drunk Driving
Jean PELLETIER – Drunk Driving
Ian MONTGOMERY – Impaired Driving
Ryan CHALUPA – Drunk Driving
Fabrizzio COMANDARI BAIRES – Drunk Driving
Tyler MACISAAC – Drunk Driving
Michael HEBERT Drunk Driving
Serious Collision Closed Intersection of Base Line and Londesboro Road
David KAMINSKY – Drunk Driving
Jean Anne WHIFFIN – Impaired Driving
Shayne HAYNER Was Arrested
Martin JAMES – Drunk Driving
Christopher DAYMAN Was Arrested
James BROOME Was Arrested
Anthony BABOOLALL – Drunk Driving
Colton HIGGINS Was Arrested
Drug Bust – Names Released
FOXTON – Drunk Driving, Hit & Run
Rebecca WATSON – Impaired Driving
Douglas BEST – Assault
Olga Antonov – Drunk Driving
Barkomal UPPAL – Drunk Driving, Hit & Run
Brian TRENHOLME – Drunk Driving
Citizen Charged With “Omit to assist peace officer”
David BURGER – Cocaine
Kyle OLDS Arrested Again
Berat BERBEROGLU Was Arrested
Jacob LECLAIR – Drunk Driving
Police Warn Of Fake Foreigners
Kieren BOLDUC – Assault & Threats
David SCHOUTEN – Drunk Driving
Aaron ARCHIBALD Was Arrested Again
Fatal Collision
William SCHARF Was Arrested
Kuldeep DHIMAN Charged Following Collision
Corey GIBSON – Impaired Driving
Kelly ZOHR – Drunk Driving
Break & Enter – Adam Judges Arrested
Rebecca PURNWASIE – Drunk Driving
Andrew WYKURZ – Assault, Hit & Run
Silence Is Golden And Now Law: The Corporation Of North Huron Mandates Bystanderism
Fatal Collision
Another Homicide
Sankeethan NAGARAJAH Was Arrested
Brent SEWARD – Drunk Driving
Brodie GRIFFITHS – Drunk Driving
Alankrit BHATNAGAR – Drunk Driving
Brandon WALTON JINTES – Drunk Driving
More Impaired Drivers Arrested – Names Released
Marissa STEACY Was Arrested
James HARDER Was Arrested Again
Drug Bust – 2 Arrested
More Impaired Drivers
Kraig MINZEN – Drunk Driving
Repeat Offender Arrested For Domestic Assault #WaitInTheTruck
Nathaniel KANE – Drunk Driving
Two Arrested On 401
Crystal FEVREAU Was Arrested
More Impaired Drivers Arrested
Robert BROCK Arrested Following Collision
STEWART Arrested For Drunk Driving
Kevin LEE – Assault
Chad Parkinson – Break & Enter
Alice Munro’s Betrayal: A Shocking Example of Bystanderism That North Huron Refuses To Condemn #EndTheAbuse
Fatal Collision
Fatal Collision
Martin Ariel LANDIZ OROZCO – Impaired Driving
Buck & Jo’s Exonerated: Judge MacDonald Overturns Covid Convictions – Error In Law
$500,000 Goderich Crime Spree – KURTIS GREEN Arrested Again
Myles Zacharias Was Arrested
More Impaired Drivers Arrested
More Spousal Abuse #WaitInTheTruck
Matthew SAMOAIO Was Arrested
Amber MARKHAM – Drunk Driving
Canaan ATKINSON – Hit & Run, Drunk Driving
Drug Bust – Names Released
Samuel LOGUE – Drunk Driving
Drunk Driver Arrested In Kincardine
Blaine BOX – Drunk Driving
Pedophile Arrested Again #WaitInTheTruck
Hunter FIELDING – Drunk Driving, Threats
4 Arrested For Theft – Names Released
Jonathan CAMBOURIS – Impaired Driving
Joseph BARRETT – Impaired Driving
Warren ANGER – Drunk Driving
Missing Person Found Deceased
Graham HALSEY – Impaired Driving
Drug Bust – FALCONER & PARKS
Haley SAUNDERS – Drunk Driving
Braeden TRIST – Assault With Weapon
Stolen Vehicles Recovered – Names Released
$630,000 Drug Bust
Huron Murder Update: Police Seek Witnesses
More Impaired Drivers Arrested
Cody Horan Was Arrested Again
Shawn LECOURS – Cocaine
Drug Bust – Names Released
Sandra ARSENAULT – Impaired Driving
Alain MORIN – Drunk Driving
Chance MATTINAS – Drunk Driving
Drug Bust – Names Released
Fatal Motorcycle Vs Deer Collision
Zander Martin Arrested Again – Details Released
Small Boat Goes Over Falls – One Dead
Armed Robbery – Names Released
Gurlal SINGH – Impaired Driving
Drug Bust – Names Released
Joseph NAGY – Drunk Driving
Christopher CHILDS – Drunk Driving
49 Year Old From Lucan Arrested – Name Released
2 More Impaired Drivers Arrested
Michael MEADE – Drunk Driving
Peter WYONCH – Drunk Driving
Dine & Dash Leads To Numerous Charges – Names Released
Ashanti SKEAD – Drunk Driving
Numerous Arrests
Eric CHAMPAGNE – Impaired Driving
Hope EWING – Drunk Driving
Armand AUGER – Drunk Driving
Dylan NUTT Was Arrested
Kevin THOMAS Was Arrested
Derek GOODING – Drunk Driving
Raymond LENDRUM – Assault
Daveandrei MORANTE – Impaired Driving
Douglas KYOMYA Was Arrested
Benjaman LEWIS – Drunk Driving
Robert PELLETIER – Drunk Driving
3 More Impaired Drivers Arrested
Steven RICHARD Was Arrested – Details Released
Drug Bust – Names Released
Samuel SHELDON – Drunk Driving
Lamar ALDERMAN-LONG – Drunk Driving
Gopinder SOHI – Hit & Run, Impaired Driving
Jeffrey PAWLOWSKY Was Arrested
3 More Impaired Drivers Arrested
Deep SHAH – Drunk Driving
Derrick GEORGE – Drunk Driving
Dwayne CLODD – Assault With Weapon
UPDATE: Family Shot To Death
Murder Update: Police Seeking Public Assistance
John-Michel BOTTOMLEY Was Arrested
Daniel LESLIE – Assault With Weapon
Darren ERICKSON – Drunk Driving
David MARTIN Was Arrested Again
Horst KOKE – Assault With Weapon
Deborah Janice MACLEOD – Drunk Driving
Christopher COLE Was Arrested
Cassandra Pinnell Was Arrested
Tyler COPEGOG Arrested Again
Danny LANDRY Was Arrested
Two Arrested – Names Released
More Impaired Drivers Arrested
Jasmine LACHINETTE – Impaired Driving
Ethan COPENACE – Impaired Driving
Kelsey GAGNON – Drunk Driving
Terrance CHERRY – Drunk Driving
Kyle BARR Was Arrested
More Impaired Drivers Arrested
4 Arrested In Drug Bust
2 From Meaford Arrested For Break & Enter
Marilyn HAYWARD – Drunk Driving
Drug Bust – Names Released
Hit & Run & Assault – Two Arrested
Nicolas WALL Was Arrested
Two More Impaired Drivers Arrested
Anthony RENAUD Was Arrested
Kara PEPPER Was Arrested
SIU Invokes Mandate Into Tiny Township Fatal Crash
Judge to Rule on Appeal of Fines Against Wingham Coffee Shop
2 Arrested In Drug Bust – Names Released
Two From Meaford Arrested
Murder In Central Huron
Conner RODWELL Was Arrested
Ian MACDONALD – Drunk Driving
Lamar JOHNSON Was Arrested Again
Ronald ALLENSEN – Drunk Driving
Drug Bust – Names Released
Troy MOREAU Was Arrested Again
Jeffery L. M. CAZABON – Sexual Assault
Crispus BOSWORTH Was Arrested
Cocaine Bust
Two More Impaired Drivers Arrested
Brittany DEROUIN – Drunk Driving
Bradley WHITE Was Arrested
Death Investigation In Central Huron
More Impaired Drivers
David AUBE Was Arrested
More Impaired Drivers
Mason FEX Was Arrested
Austin RIGGS Was Arrested
Break & Enter – 2 Arrested
Nikko YOUCKE Arrested – Meth A Factor
Scott CONNELLY From Lucknow Arrested – Details Released
Amanda DA COSTA GOMEZ Was Arrested
Saindon BLAKE – Drunk Driving
Michael MORGAN – Impaired Driving
Jeremy PEARCE Was Arrested
Jeffrey DOUGLASS – Assault & Threats
David Russell – Drunk Driving
3 More Impaired Drivers Arrested – Names Released
Scott Weiler Was Arrested Again
Protest Parade: Not Our Leader, We Won’t Follow You #WinghamWakening
Brooke BLAIR – Drunk Driving
Nickolaus ROWE Was Arrested
Reeve Exposed As A Cold Blooded Bully In Wingham Homecoming Parade #EndTheAbuse
Talwinder Singh Was Arrested
Repeat Offender Arrested Again
Johnathan TEAHEN Was Arrested
Andrew KANIEWSKI Was Arrested
Mahmud BADHON Was Arrested
Cocaine Bust – Names Released
Fatal Collision
Misty Hilts Was Arrested
Brock NIELSEN Was Arrested
Sage MIGWANS Arrested Following Collision
Fatal Collision
Leroy VINCENT Was Arrested
Exeter Drug Bust, Two Arrested
Assault With Weapon
Steven GRANBERG Arrested Again
Prabhjot RANDHAWA: Drunk Driving
Drug Bust: Names Released
2 More Impaired Drivers Arrested: Names Released
Armed Robbery
Ahmad MOHAMMAD NAZIM Was Arrested Again
Update: Names Of Four Deceased Released
Sukhwinder SINGH Was Arrested
Fatal Collision
Fatal Pedestrian Collision
Justin LACOSSE Was Arrested
Fatal Collision
Drug & Weapons Bust
Lawrence MACADAM Was Arrested
Peter BACK: Drunk Driving
Amanda STARLING Was Arrested
Attempted Armed Robbery: Names Released
$600,000 Worth of Stolen Property Recovered, Numerous Charges Laid
Clayton WHITE Was Arrested Again
Another Grooming/Pride Flag Stolen
Do You Recognize This Theft Suspect
Kristan MILLER: Drug Trafficking
John KOSKI: Drunk Driving
Fatal Collision: Train Vs Vehicle
Curtis ANDERSON: Break & Enter
Donald WILSON Was Arrested
Ted DIETSCH Was Arrested
Kristan MILLER Was Arrested
Trisha RENNIE Was Arrested